Live Let Thrive Podcast
Airbnb, PadSplit, Corporate Rentals, Arbitrage, and Live Let Thrive cover all the creative ways to rent out your properties to maximize profits. We also cover creative ways to buy properties. Come along for the ride and have some fun along the way!
Live Let Thrive Podcast
Episode 78: Insane STR Fines, Police Shakedowns, Cities Playing Dirty! Joy Williams Fights Back!
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Joy Williams of the Home Sharing Association of America recounts fighting New York City's Airbnb crackdown - including $10,000 in personal fines, warrantless door-knocking by police and building inspectors, and threats that could reach $100,000 for some hosts. She secured a temporary injunction blocking a law that would've forced platforms to hand over host data to law enforcement, arguing Fourth Amendment protections. The episode covers the hotel lobby's influence on city council, rent prices actually dropping despite the city's claims, and the revelation that Arlington PD has started knocking on Texas hosts' doors after collecting contact information at a city meeting.
Topics include New York's enforcement tactics against short-term rentals, the lawsuit over host data sharing, the difference between home sharing and remote hosting, gentrification arguments used against Airbnb, union workers unknowingly aligned with hotel CEOs making $11 million, and strategies for hosts facing bans - including never opening the door without a warrant.
Become a Live Let Thrive Insider: For $3 a month, get every new episode 5 days before everyone else. Raw, uncut, and early. Join here: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2641586/subscribe
Julie George's Million Dollar Host
STR mastermind: 140+ operators, 3 live calls a week. Code MYKA = 10% off your first payment.
Springboard to Wealth
Real estate mentorship with Thach Nguyen & Stephanie Owens: education, accountability, live events.
Real estate mentorship with Thach Nguyen & Stephanie Owens: education, accountability, live events.
Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.
Work with us. Interested in professional management or consulting?
Myka — Sharebnb: www.sharebnb.com
Steve — Argest Rentals: www.ArgestRentals.com
Sign up for PadSplit with Steve's link and get a free 1-on-1 PadSplit strategy call with Stevie Stacks: padsplit.com/hosts
Myka's other podcast, Entrepremarriage — building wealth without losing the marriage: youtube.com/@Entrepremarriage
All our links: linktr.ee/liveletthrive
#airbnb #airbnbhost #shorttermrentals #midtermrentals #padsplit #rentbytheroom #coliving #corporatehousing #BRRRR #realestate #realestateinvesting #VRBO #shareeconomy #airbnbsuperhost #airbnbpodcast #sharebnb #liveletthrive #liveletthrivepodcast #biggerpockets #directbookings #bookdirect #dfwrealestate
Cold open: the $10,000 in fines Joy Williams owes New York City
SPEAKER_03Wow. And so you said they gave you some tickets. I've heard some outrageous numbers. Like how m how much are they fining people for having Airbnbs?
SPEAKER_02Well, I think it varies, but uh well I know it varies. But so my at the end of the day, I've paid them a thousand plus and I owe them probably ten thousand more. So I know some other people who owe ten and fifteen and thirty thousand. And then some people, I do know someone else who told me, and I haven't seen it to verify it myself, but I think she owes almost a hundred thousand. So what happens is once they come in, they treat you like you're a hotel. So if you don't have sprinkler system, proper sprinkler system, proper fire extinguishers, if you have locks on in interior doors, uh a whole host of things, they'll write a ticket for any of that.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Live Let Thrive, a podcast about the Airbnb life, the share economy, and everything in between. Here are your hosts, Micah and Steve.
Introduction and Joy Williams from the Home Sharing Association of America
SPEAKER_06Hello, hello, hello.
SPEAKER_03And welcome back to another exciting episode of Live Let Draw. Yeah, and today, uh what's episode 78? And today we got a special guest coming all the way from New York. Uh, we have Joy Williams with the Committee Association of Bike. How are you doing, Joy?
SPEAKER_02I'm good. Thanks for having me.
SPEAKER_03Definitely, definitely. Thanks for coming on, because I know you're probably busy, um, especially with everything that's going on in New York. Um matter of fact, because we we've just seen in the news, because we're in Texas, and we've just seen in the news
The temporary injunction blocking New York's host data sharing law
SPEAKER_03that you guys actually had a big victory. So how is that how is that coming along?
SPEAKER_02So we did have a big victory, so it it but it's a temporary victory. So it is a temporary injunction uh against the law that the city council passed, which they basically wanted to take all of our information, those people who are using Airbnb or other any other home sharing platform, and then give it to the Office of Special Enforcement, which is uh basically law enforcement. So the the police of the Airbnb world. So yeah, so the judge said that this is a violation of Fourth Amendment rights for the companies. So that was great that he's not going to um let this law go into effect in um and when it was scheduled to go into effect in February and that the trial can commence. So we don't know what the city's gonna do, but we're prepared to continue to fight.
SPEAKER_03Wow. Wow, that's awesome. I mean, at least 'cause I um the city that we have a city down here called uh Grapevine, and they just kind of had the same thing. They banned Airbnb, and the everyone what they did was they pretty much got an injunction against the city and kind of puts a temporary kind of like a I guess you could consider it a grace period, right, if you will. So you can continue to do it, I guess, and without any fines or penalties. So and and I noticed, and one thing I uh what really stuck out to me about your group was you guys are home chairing. In your association, do you guys distinct your g your yourselves from like people who, hey, they have a house over here and they Airbnb that, or you guys stick it only to people that home chair, like people that live in live in their property?
SPEAKER_02So we don't we're we don't make that distinction really, because really the problem with making that distinction is to assume that we want to agree with some part of the law and we don't, and then to say that, you know, we're defining what kind of property you have. So we're most of us are sharing our homes and live in them, but that that there's no distinction for that in the law. So the current law says that anybody, whether you live in the house or not, if i if you're s if you're renting out an entire unit and I own a three family, if I'm renting out the entire unit two or three, then it's illegal.
SPEAKER_05Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_02So we so we don't we're not judging that because we think the law is wrong and that we need to fight the law. Right? So we yeah. So we include everybody. We include people who don't want to who don't really care for people who use Airbnb. And that would be that would include like um people who do b bread and breakfast, the more traditional ones in the city. There's no there's no law that permits them to do that, but they like to make a distinction for themselves. They like to think of themselves differently, and they don't want to um combine themselves with us. They think there's some benefit to it, and there's really I don't see it, but but we we would welcome them if they want to participate with us too.
SPEAKER_03So Okay. Wow. So was like during this whole home sharing while people were doing Airbnb, uh, because one of the problems we had
Tax collection differences between New York City and upstate counties
SPEAKER_03here in Texas was the cities were actually the city of Arlington in particular, which is where the Dallas Cowboys play. They were actually collecting taxes from the host, and then they were trying to put pretty much stri uh stipulations on it. So what it but they had to kind of overturn it because they were collecting tax money. Was the New York City of New York or any of the boroughs in New York were they collecting tax money from any of the hosts or so no, and not in any of the boroughs they weren't collecting taxes because I I think I think they recognize that would be a problem.
SPEAKER_02But in some of the counties in um Upper State New York and upstate New York, they are collecting taxes. So and some of them some of those counties have made agreements with the with uh Airbnb. So it depends on where you live, specifically how this is uh um take you know, how they how they look at it, and it's different in every county.
SPEAKER_03Wow. Okay. If so, because I know you guys are particularly in New York, do you guys like a plan plan on expanding to other states, like have a H H H SAA chapter in New York uh not New York, but in Texas or Washington State or something like that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so we plan to expand wherever anybody needs needs the support. So we have helped had um talked to other people and tried to help them out when they when they request from us. So and there are a couple of other organizations throughout the country I think that are similar, but yeah, we definitely want to expand and we feel that even if even if not under our banner, that we need to be a more organized force um nationally because that's what the hotel industry is doing and how they're um you know getting information out that is really disinformation and we want people to be informed no matter where they are. But I think as as a collective we have more power and just more information and then we can figure out what it is we're fighting. I think in New York it's hard for people to really know what's happening because the city's not helping us in that regard.
SPEAKER_06So you think uh uh this is Steve, by the way. How you doing, Joy?
SPEAKER_05Good, Steve.
City council members receiving money from the hotel lobby
SPEAKER_05How are you?
SPEAKER_06Pretty good, pretty good. Um sipping on a corona currently. Um anyway anyways, um a question. Do you think that the city council is in the pockets of the of the hotel industry?
SPEAKER_02Definitely. Well we know we know they're we know they are, and we know largely that they are receiving money from from the city uh from the hotel lobby. Uh that is public information, so I'm not speaking out of turn on that. Um there when this law came up to be passed, the um the city council knew in advance because the the New York affiliate of the ACLU said that this is a violation of Fourth Amendment rights, among other things. So they knew that. But when they came to pass it, not one person spoke up against it in any form. So really how the laws get passed the physical day when they pass them, the actual day when they pass them in the in the um in the si in the chamber, they they have a number of laws that they pass. So each person will uh affirm that they're gonna pass all of these things. So they're not putting it up anything that they think is not gonna pass. So well, some people will say, I have an issue with this, I have an issue with that. Even though I have an issue with this law, we're gonna pass it. I'm gonna my I'm gonna vote for it. Or they'll say that I'm gonna vote against it. But really, what happened that day was not a single person in that chamber said anything against this law. So um clearly this is a problem to us that because this is our new speaker Corey Johnson's initiative, he came out highly against um Airbnb when he s when he started and the and he got Carolina Rivera to in to introduce this bill. So those are the people that are were standing on on the side of the bill. Um and the and the people feel that they have to support that, otherwise whatever they're do for the rest of the session won't be heard. So there's a problem in our structure, but a problem in this bill, and they and they are all, not all, but the majority of the people in the city council do get money from the from the hotel lobby, so they are definitely in their pocket.
SPEAKER_03Wow.
SPEAKER_06That's crazy.
SPEAKER_03It really is. And and I'm happy you keep bringing up the Fourth Amendment. So it sounds like uh the pretty much the city of New York had people actually going to people's houses and walking in and inspecting them.
SPEAKER_02Well, so there are two things. So this the the the city has been doing that. So and I'll tell you about me, but the the law itself says that they want they want so much information. They want our names, addresses, our our our uh what kind of units we have, and we're fine with that. But they also want things on how much money we're making. They they want a whole like where this money is going, the accounts that this money is going to. So they they want um more information that is reasonable. So they also the other fact that the the the New York chapter that ACLU talked about was the the data supplier or the or the the company that the the the uh the office of special enforcement used to aggregate this information is the same that's used by ICE and and the CIA. So there's no no protections or provisions to protect our data and our information. And we live in a country, and some people forget this, that you just don't give over your space or right to search and seizure just because you have some some um wild complaint. You you need specific subpoena ability and the and the uh and there needs to be some evidence of a crime. So innocent people should be able to have the private enjoyment of their home and their data, and this doesn't do that. So but what the city has been doing before and they still do is they send out people from the office of special enforcement. There'll be a a person from the office of special enforcement, a person from the building department, a person from the fire department, and a police officer.
Warrantless door-knocking by police, building inspectors, and fire department
SPEAKER_02And when they come to the door without a warrant, they will knock. If they can get in, they will get in. Uh if a door is open or if they can open a door, they will come in. They will come without a warrant. They they've done this time and time again. They came up to my door, they've been to my house three times.
SPEAKER_04Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_02And um they will convince people that they need to let them in. And they they're not advising people of they have a r a right to privacy and they don't have to let anybody in, even though there's a police officer, unless he has a warrant. So once you're in, what they once they get in, they write tickets for anything from the top of your house to the bottom, wherever they are. So and that's their goal. There it's not a compassionate thing because when they came to me, I had the second time they came to me, or it could have been the third time, they came to me, I had gone to court once and I thought I was doing the right thing. I had gotten back a dismissal for one part, but not for the other. So I assumed that they were together. And the actual other part went to another address. It didn't come to my address. So I um I I you know, I was doing what I thought was right, and as I explained that to them, they didn't care. They just wrote more tickets. I went and I got the documentation to say, like, this is what I have, and I and this is what I think I'm doing, and I think this is right. And they're like, mm, no. So problematic.
SPEAKER_06That's kind of scary, um, they're Yeah, being this is the United States of America and they can use like Gestapo type tactics to just break in and or not break in, but coerce you to get your get your door open so they can go and um shake you down for money. That's that's like uh mafia type stuff right there.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it it feels that way. It feels that way. So even when I spoke to the mayor in uh August of 2016, before he was elected, to say that, you know, I I didn't really want to debate him on the law. I I knew that there's a process and we need to work to change the law. But he talked about how we had to do this because of these bad actors and these large buildings, but that's not what's happening. There are some bad actors and there are some large buildings that need to be addressed. But for the most part, and they know by my address they can look up the property that I own a three family house. So the the claims that they're making are largely untrue. I'm not permanently taking off um housing off the market because in fact it was off the market. Well, at least one of the units was off the market anyway. So I'm not obligated to rent it out. It can be e it can be open. It can be you know, but they're telling me if I want to rent it, I have to rent it to someone for for um a longer period of time. Whereas if you buy a house and and the same property, you can take the units and make them one, so you can permanently destroy uh units of housing. Which has which is happening around here, the developers are buying up units and turning them into single family homes. So if you have a lot of money, you can make a single family home, but if you need more money, you can't rent out for a short period of time.
SPEAKER_06So th that's ironic to me, because they're one of the big concerns you hear people, oh, they're you know, they're taking away they're taking houses off the market because they're turning them into Airbnbs, whereas they'll allow someone to go buy in a multi-unit and turn it into one, literally taking uh two, three, or four units off the market. But they're cool with that.
Women making less and how Airbnb bridges the income gap in Harlem
SPEAKER_02Yeah, they're fine with that. They're fine with it. So and they're the the the um complaint is that this is aiding in gentrification when in fact it's a reverse. So the even the controller he he issued a report on how um women make less than than men and black women in particular make less. So a lot of the people in Harlem where where I am that I know who are doing this are women who make less. So the opportunity for them to make more in their houses to invite people into those other other units that they have to make more to sort of bridge that gap. Um unfortunately they're not interested in that. They're not interested in trying to figure out what would be an anti-gentrification stance, they're not interested in that, and they have no plans on any of that. And it's disingenuous on the behalf of the of the hotel industries to say that they're interested in it at all. They they're not. They're just interested in their own profit.
SPEAKER_06Hmm. And how how is Airbnb and VRBO, how are they helping y'all in this fight? Good question.
SPEAKER_02So, um V VRBO hasn't really helped us in this fight at this point. So the the lawsuit, you you probably know that VRBO and Home Away are owned by Expedia. I think Home Away was the name party in the lawsuit, so they joined with Airbnb. So Airbnb ha uh has been first on the forefront of getting hosts together and building community. So some of that community building has been around uh advocacy and and helping us fight um you know, fight fight the fight locally in the city and the state. So we we are working on developing our partnership even further this year so that we can be more coordinated. And at the same time we really want to make sure that people know the voice of the host. I think what happens in this conversation is people get so um angry with Airbnb. It makes no sense to me, but they get angry with Airbnb and they forget that Airbnb is just a platform we use and as as hosts it's it's nice, but that we're just using it as a platform. We don't own stocking, at least we don't know, right? They propose to somebody. But we don't own stock and it's just the platform we use, and we use other and many of us use other platforms, whatever is gonna work best for us. So that uh what what our goal is, is to develop that partnership while still remaining independent.
SPEAKER_06I also okay, a little series of questions
The officer's threat about other ways of getting in your house
SPEAKER_06here. Um I I assume I assume there's some been some fighters in your family and and uh what's provoked you to take on uh such a fight like this?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so yeah, I pretty much try to do what's right, but when someone came to my door and really it was a bully tactic, so when the when the um first officer came to my door and he w uh was with three other guys, and when he walked off the steps he turned around and said to me, We have other ways of getting in your house.
SPEAKER_04What?
SPEAKER_02So I took that as a threat and you know, I try not to give in to bullies. So, you know, in my perspective that this house is a blessing to me, God bless me with it. Uh, you know, I had the money, I figured all that stuff out, but it was definitely a blessing and I felt like I have to stand up for my right to have my house and to do what I think is right. The other problem with it is I went to a hearing in January of 2017 and um the Office of Special Enforcement never told us after that hearing, which was a rules hearing, how they were going to implement the rules. So if you wanted me to stop doing it, all you had to let me know was you would come after me if I did it. Then I could have figured out what to do that was right. So on the on the one hand, you're saying I shouldn't be doing this. On the other hand, I can't find out the information about what what is happening until people start getting violations, until I start getting them, because I thought I was doing what was right. I thought it made sense for me because I live in my house and I own this house, that I could rent out those units. It's not subject to rent stabilization or um because it is three units, so I figured I could do w what I wanted to my house and they're telling with my house. And they're saying no, you can't. But they didn't even have the the courtesy to say this is how we're implementing the law after we spent all day in a hearing to hear to tell them what we thought. They never issued those rules. And when we met with the Executive Director of the Office of Special Enforcement, he acknowledged that his website wasn't up to date. There's no place that anybody's trying to do this, they can find out that information.
SPEAKER_03Wow. And so you said they gave you some tickets. I've heard some outrageous numbers. Like how m how much are they fining people for having Airbnbs?
SPEAKER_02Well, I think it varies, but uh well, I know it varies. But so my at the end of the day, I've paid them a thousand plus and I owe them probably ten thousand more. So I know some other people who owe ten and fifteen and thirty thousand, and then some people, I do know someone else who told me, and I haven't seen it to verify it myself, but I think she owes almost a hundred thousand. So what happens is once they come in, they treat you like you're a hotel. So if you don't have sprinkler system, proper sprinkler system, proper fire extinguishers, if you have locks on in interior doors, uh a whole host of things, they'll write a ticket for any of that. So it makes it um very difficult for people. And there's no opportunity to cure this defect, or even to say, I'm not doing it any longer, you shouldn't be finding me for it. So I think that's the problem because I think in commercial buildings, if the if the um building department comes and issues a violation, they have an opportunity to correct it. We don't.
SPEAKER_03Wow. That is crazy. And so you said they do want to put like a cap on how long you have to rent. Like here, like when they cook caps, we usually switch over to like corporate renting, renting to like traveling nurses. What's like the minimum stay that you got that that the city wants for someone to stay to not consider it a short-term rental?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so that would be 30 days. So tw 29 days is illegal, 30 days is illegal.
SPEAKER_06Okay. Like everywhere else. I I have an interesting, like, out of left field question. And g and I'm saying it because you mentioned keywords, you know, like um gentrification. Uh we spoke of um, you know, you know, housing, whatever, taking houses off the market. Um where does the um the civil rights um part of this, what are the the people that push for civil rights, where do they fall in this um in this um pro or against um Airbnb um fight going on?
SPEAKER_02So we have had some people that ha are in the more traditional civil rights fight, and they found the side of Airbnb and and and other platforms such as Airbnb. And they do that because it does provide us an opportunity to stay in our homes. So, you know, what happens traditionally is when a neighborhood is on the upswing, right? The the um taxes go up, the um other people move in and making things more expensive for the people who've been there for a long time. So this gives people who've been there for a long time an opportunity to make some additional income. There are a lot of people who have have multiple uh townhouses that are multiple units that use any one of those single units only for family or friends or they might have you know just guests. So so those people so that's why people are are in support of it because they know that it provides people an another opportunity to make additional income and actually stay in the neighborhood.
SPEAKER_06And and and I I kind of asked that too because like I I see articles all the time and I and I and I saw the article about um y'all fighting this y'all had this victory in New York. And and it's funny and the article was even pro I mean it was saying hey you know the Airbnb people had this little victory whatever. But the picture they showed you know it talked about the Airbnb fight was a bunch of people of of color like us and holding up sides against Airbnb. And that's the picture that the newspaper or not not the newspaper online paper decides to put forefront. So that's why I was asking that question. Whereas you say it's the opposite people uh of the civil rights you know movement are for Airbnb but if you look at the news you look at the the footage they give us the from LA to New York it's people of color looks like they're against Airbnb.
SPEAKER_02So if you look at if you think about it what has happened is some of the hotel trade or associations, some of those lobbies represent um the the lower levels of hotel workers, right? Because the the trade organizations themselves they represent the the management in the in hotels. But so the the lower levels of of the trade organizations of the of you know the working class and I I I mean I say lower level is in lower um ec receiving lower economics from the hotel. So the the working class workers you know these proud individuals who've been working for quite some time um in this fight they're aligned with the uh with the h the overall hotel lobby which is represents the the the CEOs and the companies and the CEOs making eleven million dollars, right? So eleven million dollars to someone making fifteen dollars an hour. So those those the hotel trade is aligned on other issues with other organizations that um want to protect union workers. So they have positioned it such that union workers may feel that they're as threat. But the interesting thing that happens is when we're sitting in chambers with our our fellow uh workers they and they listen to what people are saying, they do recognize that some of this what we're talking about makes sense. And some people who are in HSA used to work in hotels. Some of them find themselves out of work and needing to uh rent their space to other people right so I think um it is convenient for for newspapers to do that but it's positioned that way from from the hotel trade to say let's put all these working class people together. So it it makes it seem like if they believe the argument that the hotel trades is telling them that this is against them and against working class people that they should be for for stopping Airbnb, which is not true. So a couple of things we know like if if a black person or a person of color has a house and they're selling it next to a a a white person, the person of color m makes less money. This is what we know. It's not something that Airbnb did. So when they talk about that black people make less money than white people in Airbnb units, I believe it 'cause that's what happens in the general market. But for for other things. But it's not it's not caused by Airbnb. So they want to manipulate the story to talk it to make it seem like that this is a problem. So we have other people like some people that uh work at the National Action Network which you know uh uh Al Straffin's organization and Danny Glover, people who are focused on economic development who are on our side but there are other organizations that are aligned with the hotel trade and because they support them they come out sometimes.
SPEAKER_06That's uh it's a tangled web it seems right it is a tangled web.
SPEAKER_02And the people in the hotel trade themselves they support any demonstration because they're paid to show up oh they're paid to show up yeah that's crazy. You can tell they're paid to show up because if you're sitting inside the chamber and it hit the clock hits whatever time they get up and leave because they do not say a minute past they're getting pay time.
SPEAKER_06They clock out Yeah that's crazy. So I mean it's it's super brave of you to to want to be at the forefront of this fight, especially in the most visible city you know on maybe on the planet. And I'm sure but I mean
Being naive about speaking up and becoming a target
SPEAKER_06when before you did this were you afraid that there was going to be like a giant target on your back and they were going to go after you every turn that they could, the city?
SPEAKER_02No, so I think I was a little naive in that. So I did speak up a lot and I do think my speaking up helped them land at my door, right? So but after they came to my door it's like you already have my name, you already have my number um how can I hide from anything? So yeah, so I was a I was a little naive on how that how that worked. Um so you know it at this point is be underc be as exposed as possible because if something happens then we're gonna know where it came from. Right? So if you're coming after me again because I'm I'm following the rules according to what they are I disagree with them but I'm following them according to what you say they are. I'm doing I'm doing my part um but you know I can't walk around in fear of the city and no one should. And you know the the thing to me is all these progressive uh legislators are not being progressive and they're on the one hand spewing one thing one day and then against us the next. So we need to hold them accountable. And I like some of the other people wasn't really that politically active before but now that I am it's like okay we we have to fight. We can't let this happen.
SPEAKER_03Right. So if New York today were say hey Airbnb's banned the injunction gives up and they ban Airbnbs would would you continue to do it? Like what would your exit strategy be to transition into something else?
SPEAKER_02Because that's what we always ask because I know they're trying to ban it here in Arlington and I've I tell people I'm I'm I always wait till enforcement but it sounds like enforcement's already at your door what would be your exit strategy well so technically I'm I'm I'm out of the short term rental market so technically I'm doing 30 day plus and that's all I'm doing. But the that law to be clear the law was only about um sharing our data and sharing our information. The law the law right now in the city is that you can't have more than two people in a unit like if you're sharing with two people that are unrelated you can you can only have two people but you can't share in any unit without the host being present for more than thirty day for for less than thirty days. So it is illegal in the city for anybody to do it. People all over the place don't recognize it. So all those listings where people really aren't there, they're illegal because the city is going after those people. So that so you know I might go back to doing it um longer term just because I want to, you know, hunker down and fight it and not be bothered with the with this fight for now and then do and then go back to it at some other point because the law is going to catch up. People are going to fight and that when people really recognize that what they're doing is legal because they don't know it's illegal. They thought there are so many people that own um there are so many people that own one and two family homes that think that what they're doing is legal and it's not. So there are eight hundred and sixty thousand uh five four five family and fewer homes in the city. And I think the the number of those that are Airbnb listed is is minuscule. So the actual impact is small but the people who are doing it they think they're legal. They think they're legal. So once they figure out they're not legal then hopefully they'll all join and be more active in the fight to uh make it legal and then we can have the law change and we're looking to spend some time with the state again this year to pass legislation that will make it legal and start a registration process. So I'm not opposed to giving the the city my information just like I registered and get my driver's license to register to to do short term rental. They just don't get all of my information. There's no reason that they need to know how much I'm making it's not their business. I file my taxes that's how they should get it but they shouldn't get it on a month by month basis on on how much they're how much we're getting from each person. It's not their business. They shouldn't know there are a whole bunch of things that they shouldn't know. I I have a right to privacy and I I think that they're overstepping their bounds. So we want to make sure that that everybody knows what the city is after and everybody knows what what what we want. We want fair clear rules and they're not clear and people think that this victory is a the end game this victory is just temporary and it doesn't change
Working on fair registration rules versus the city demanding all financial data
SPEAKER_02the law and they're still going after people that is crazy.
SPEAKER_06That's cool that you're um you're at the forefront leading the fight and um we we really appreciate it all the way over here from Arlington. And before we dive further into this into the fight part um we forgot to well we'll ask you a little bit how did you start um Airbnb yourself? How did you um choose to do home share as opposed to you know off site and yeah and how did it how how was that going and how is it you know how did it change your life?
SPEAKER_02Yeah so I I um was I I was actually at a conference and one of my tenants texted me and said that he was breaking his lease. So I was debating what to do because I'm working on my own uh venture to improve the health of people of color. So which is you know my personal experiment. It's not easy to do clearly we still have these problems but it was a way for me to um make additional income and then cover my bills as I worked on my own business model. So it it went well and it was you know after I first I I listed and I I left like a month later I got my first first um guest and then after that it it it was going very well. And then I ended up listing the other unit also which is where I was living and I just moved downstairs into the unit with my sister. Um so it was so it was going well it was helping me pay my bills and keep on top of things um and to do the the programming that I wanted to do. So that's why I started doing it. And then you know it changed when I had to stop doing it. So it it definitely put a strain on me.
SPEAKER_03Wow. Wow everyone always has an interesting story how they got started. Um Wow so when was the HSAA created?
SPEAKER_02So it is officially a year old we had our first meeting last January I think it was January eighth but we had our first meeting last January there were about probably about twelve of us. So the group at the the core group is a little smaller at the moment. Some people have you know moved in and out of doing uh home sharing and and aren't and spending their time doing other things. But a pretty committed group of people. So we um we meet pretty regularly and um this year we're gonna change up some of the things we're doing because we really need to advance our issue issues some more so that's why we're trying to work on our partnership with with Airbnb and then we'll be reaching out to the other platforms as well um to join in the fight with us.
SPEAKER_03Has and another thing, has Airbnb done anything for your group specifically to fight the bands or well yeah so they we we work pretty well with Airbnb um especially the people in the New York office and we um you know sometimes they'll host meetings for us in their space um and we work with them.
SPEAKER_02I I've been on television with them. Um so yeah so so we we work well with them. Uh they're a good group of people though and they're very committed to the fight. So we've gone to Al Albany together and they've had some other presentations. So we're we're still planning on on on fighting together this year. So you know they're a company and we're hosts so all of our issues aren't a hundred percent online but I we are we are are very much aligned.
SPEAKER_06Wow okay are you um you ever thought about putting your resume in with Airbnb?
SPEAKER_02Maybe they could hook you up with a good gig I hadn't really thought about it maybe you know but I think I you know I think I think it's their advantage if if I run as executive director the HFAA, then I can be the voice the host because once you there there's this um thing that happens when when legislators start talking to people who actually work for for Airbnb, the vitriol, the hatred, the you know the space that they give is is ridiculous. And I I think it is at the point where um it's difficult for productive things to happen when it it is Airbnb and um legislators. When it when we have constituents, I think they ha they haven't paid as much attention to us as much but but they recognize that we can impact whether or not they keep their jobs. But we're we're hoping to um make more of an imp impact on them to let them know that we're really disappointed that that not one of them, not one single person on the city can I get it, I get and then we need to come at it to a different way. So the city likes to talk about well we need to meet with Airbnb to um to come up with a law and I think that's ridiculous. You need to come up with something that's fair and just and um that actually helps the community and then Airb Airbnb can implement it. Uh and and I think that we can help in Sorry you're breaking up Oh sorry about that. I said when they get in the room with Airbnb they pretty much they're just too angry to do anything productive.
SPEAKER_06Yeah just the shouting matches go on right yeah you know Airbnb's not not a hundred percent innocent here either but they they need to do a better job so we can mitigate that by working with us. Right, right, right. They need to take a more active role I think 'cause like um like uh I mean it's I mean you're New York City, you know capital of the world kind of thing. So Airbnb has a lot of um interest in the bigger cities so uh cities like us like over here in Arlington they're really not reaching out really not trying to offer us much help and you know in our struggle against um against them banning it you know altogether and we're um I think it is I mean Micah asked you earlier about uh if you're differentiating yourself from the uh remote hosts but um you said no you want it to be all packaged together and that's that's a that's a um a different angle to take because a lot of um a lot of studies allow it if you're um if you're home sharing if you open up your home
Why HSAA does not differentiate between home sharers and remote hosts
SPEAKER_06to Airbnb out of the rooms whereas what they don't want is people to just um snap up houses to turn them into Airbnb turning whole you know that's what they're saying turning whole city streets into just nothing but like a a long line of hotels little mini hotels but but most for the most part the cities haven't messed with home shares as you know as much as they have with the remote hosting but you said from the from the get go y'all didn't want to differentiate from the remote hosts and and I mean ha has there been talks to like n to okay let's just go our own way you know let them fight their fight we'll fight our fight uh well so we're not making a judgment about people we don't ask people to say X, Y, Z.
SPEAKER_02So we're not making that judgment about them. So but we do support people in particular who are who are living in their own units. So in the city though, because you know while we have over three million units of housing and some of those are in large buildings that and some of those in rent stabilized buildings. So we permit anybody to be a member. We're not telling them um that they can't be a member so they can come get the information and we we want fair rules and at the end of the day a l the rules probably will have a preference for people who are living in their spaces. Um and some of those rules in larger buildings people probably won't be able to do to do it at all and then in other places where they have rules that where they have like rules or other rules, those things will be re regulated. But according to the city everything is illegal so we weren't making that judgment on what who could come to a meeting and who could learn what's happening. Because people don't even know what they're some of them don't even know what they're doing is illegal. So it was really this there are people, get people together and let's hack it out so we can figure out what the rules are. When we started we didn't really know and we didn't know how they were going to be enforced and we didn't know what they were going after. Um so that's the judgment we're gonna be making at the end of the day we're we desperately want a proper registration and our goal is to have that in units that are not rent stabilized, which would mean five units in less um and five units sewer. We live on that property not a little bit the details everything is illegal. It's all illegal. Unless you are living in a unit and the people are in the unit with you it's illegal. It doesn't matter if you live there or not and that's not they're not saying oh if you live there we appreciate you. No, they can't stand any of it. So we need to say this is what's happening. So people know you if you don't live here or if you live here you are going to get fined.
SPEAKER_06Right, right right wow and so uh going back to the whole you know we'll touch on the home sharing a little bit I mean has it do you see it as a positive force in the neighborhoods you know where where you're at and um do you see I mean has it changed your life for the better? Not just the monetarily you know but j but meeting people from all over the world kind of thing and just like um showing them showing them the real you know the real New York?
SPEAKER_02Yeah so I think it has been good. I I've helped people who um you know they're from here so people are from over the w all over the world but from New York at the same time. They come back because their family is here but their family doesn't have enough space for them and their families so I think that's been a great opportunity. It's good other people come, students come, um and then it helps the the community our our local restaurants and other things get more support. So that's good because it helps my community on a longer term basis that you know these things are viable because other people come to them. So I think that's helpful too. Um you know my neighborhood is changing and it's it's not only what people ex would expect but mostly good. So I I think it's it has been helpful. You know some people some hosts spend a lot of time with their guests. I think for me because I have separate units, people you know, they get to do what they want to do and act as if they are a part of the community. So I think that's great too. I mean you know I'll provide information and let people know what things to go to but they can feel like they're a part of the neighborhood.
SPEAKER_06So you don't see you personally don't don't see any um negative impacts from from Airbnb.
SPEAKER_02I don't really see any negative impacts from Airbnb in my area. I think you know we could pretend that everything is always positive. I think there are some people that abuse the system because people abuse all sorts of systems. People abuse Medicaid and Medicare. I don't think we should get rid of it because people abuse it, I think we have to get rid of the abusers. So um I haven't seen that in my neighborhood I I see I see more traffic of people um taking tours, but I don't think that's because they're they're doing Airbnb I think it's just because my neighborhood is relatively popular. I do see more suitcases on the street, but you can see me almost every weekend taking a suitcase because I go if I go to Long Island, which I do a lot, I'd have a bag, you know, so I I haven't seen any real negative impact into it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. See, because here in Arlington, that's what they're complaining about. They're saying, hey, there's party houses. Um our fight's a little bit different than yours. Ours isn't really backed by the hotel industry. It's more or less backed by complaining neighbors. So when people started getting complaints, they started telling the city, then the city brought it to the forefront. Um so it sounds like our fight may be a little bit different, but I don't know if it seems like y'all probably have a tougher way to go because you're dealing with directly with the city council.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and what people have complained about party houses and and that. So I think a lot of stuff that we do is to make sure well what I do is to make sure people know you can't have a party here. And I think that's the thing that happens with remote posts, right? So if people rent a place and they know that you're not gonna be around, then they can abuse the rule and just you know ask for forgiveness, for permission. But um we do have some people. But people can have time because they know they can't. Every once in a while, people get a little loud, but they're usually around. I can let them know, like no, you gotta be quiet now. Turn it down. But I also do find that there's some people, whether or not they're experiencing a party or whatever, if they don't like the concept of therapy, and they it makes sense to them, and they don't they can make a complaint and it not be valid. So I think there's waiting that people who just like to complain about this. I remember going to an event and a woman was she was just appalled that there would be more people having suitcases coming down the street. I was like, that's crazy, but okay. So there's some of that too.
SPEAKER_03Was she born in the fifties?
SPEAKER_02No, I'm just kidding. Maybe, maybe even before, yeah, at least at least the fifties.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, as we would notice Terry, like I do feel for the people that complain here, because they are kind of part of the older community. They're more, you know, 60, 70 years old, and they just want to live in their uh their neighborhood. And I do I know I do feel like some of the hosts are to blame because they do go into those neighborhoods, start up these Airbnbs in big
Making New York City affordable for families who can't pay $300 a night
SPEAKER_03four or five bedroom homes, and of course people are throwing parties if you're advertising it for 25 people, you know. So, like you said, you gotta get rid of the abusers and don't punish everybody.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, we just need to figure out a better way of doing that.
SPEAKER_06I guess here's my take on the thing. Cause um I've been to New York um three times, New York City, and I've um I I was lucky enough to stay with a friend, you know, a couple times, and then the third time I rented a hotel. And the um hold on real quick. Uh voicemail. Okay. Alright. And so I was lucky enough to um to visit, you know, I said stayed with a friend the first couple times, and it was in Jersey City. And so, you know, outside of the city. And this and the third time we stayed in Flushing, which is outside the city also. I had to take a train into the city. And so the reason I stayed so far away is because it was um the hotels at the time were so damn expensive. And that's like, I mean, a lot of us we can't afford, like, I mean, back, you know, especially when you're younger, you can't afford, you know, two or three hundred dollars a night for a hotel. And um, we can't stay in the city, we gotta stay outside the outskirts, you know, go into the city, do the tourist things maybe, and and get and get our asses back to where we uh you know where we're staying outside the city before it's too late. And I'm like, well, I don't I see I see it as a p a big plus, a huge plus that uh we can stay at an Airbnb chair with some friends and stay in the city, spend our money in the city at the local spots, you know, not just the tourist spots that we have time to see. And then we c we don't have to like hop a train and go all the way across town and go back to like outside of the city or go to Jersey, and we're spending our money in Jersey instead of New York City, and so I it's just um I think it's a it's a it's a great thing, it's a blessing, and for you know, New York City especially or bigger cities, 'cause we get to actually experience the you know, experience it like we're locals.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And I because n first of all, n uh Jersey City is Airbnb friendly. They embrace Airbnb, so it's easier even if you were staying in Jersey City to get an Airbnb. But that is so true. So people would say I live in Harlem, so people would bring their family 'cause if you you know, if you have four people, uh you have a family and then you want to cook and you want to do all that in your space because you can save money that way and then see explore the rest of the city, that's easy to do. So it uh it would be very expensive and surprises for a lot of people to come and stay for the week that they stay usually with me in the past to to afford it. If they had to pay the high price, had to pay for food, had to pay for everything. So yeah, it does make it affordable.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, and um I guess they in other words, the city, um by being, you know, obviously backed by the hotel lobby, you know, the council, they're saying, no, we like the status quo. We like it for only rich people can come visit New York City and stay in New York City and stay in Times Square and spend five hundred bucks a night at a hotel. We like how it is right now. Don't change.
unknownMm-hmm.
SPEAKER_02They made record profits last year. And so there a couple of the claims that they're they're talking about impact them. They made record profits last year. And the actual thing they talked about how it makes rent prices go up. Rent actual real rent prices went down. So what's happening now is there are lots of uh mushy buildings and the lusty apartment owners will price the thing but give up people a discount. Because that's not what's happening. Actual real rents have gone down. So had an impact. So there are three million, there are about three million three hundred thousand units in the city, and there are fifty-five thousand Airbnb. So and fifteen percent of the people it worked out to be like point either between point eight percent and point eighteen percent that were impacting the the housing market, which is no matter how you're figuring it out, it is a uh a rounding era at best. So it's not really having that impact that the wholesale lobby or the city council would like to say.
SPEAKER_06Wow. This is a lot of great information you're giving us here, Joy. And um we really appreciate it that you're at the forefront of the fight. And if you could tell um our listeners out there, you know, I mean, bans are pretty much going on everywhere across the country, not just um not just New York, not just LA, everywhere across the country, these little, you know, cities are are throwing up these bands. And if you could like um tell our listeners, you know, uh how I mean how do what the sh what should they do to to go about, you know, fighting this, to go about, you know, getting, you know, you know, going up against the city council if they need to.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so really what they should start to do is um reach out to their legislators, join with other people who have the same interests as they do, um, and then reach out to their legislators. If they need help from us, they can find us on our Facebook page, which is the Home Showing Association of America dot AFAA1.
SPEAKER_06Okay, we'll put that in the show notes.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and then you know, because what it requires is people to become involved locally. And what happens is people who share homes aren't naturally in groups already, whereas the uh the social body is very organized around other issues. This is just another thing. So definitely start reaching out even if you call people and and let them know calling us and let them know how you feel, and organize groups of people, because the constituents matter more than the um lobby when the constituents get the the uh city council to be to not be elected the next time. So if the m if the if there are enough of you and your vo and all of your votes count, things can happen.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, yeah. I guess I guess the big thing I see is um people are afraid to go up there and fight 'cause they don't want to get a target on their back, you know. They're they're like, I'm doing it on the down low, you know, if they start passing some rules, maybe they won't find me. But yeah, I guess I mean they're pushing for legislation to go out and um and find you, so might as well fight while you can, right?
SPEAKER_02Right. And then the other thing, 'cause I I feel like it's a flopper slope. If you let them do this, they're gonna do something else. Because i they're gonna find something else to do. If they're gonna take away your right to do what you want in your house, then they'll they'll move the line. So we have to hold them to what's right because they'll just it'll be something else. If you think that's not gonna impact you. And even if you're not home sharing but you've heard about them, you really need to make sure your legislators know what you feel. They they need to know that you think you should be able to do this in your house. Now you shouldn't be able to have lawfic parties that disturb the neighborhood, but if you want people in your house, it shouldn't be a problem.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, I um that it reminds me of a story I just read about in New York City about I think it was it the mayor wanting to um uh go after bad landlords and confiscating their properties. I'm like, whoa, whoa, confiscating property. That's some that's some um communist stuff right there. I don't know.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so recognize this mayor think he's progressive. I I I don't understand what that is. He he and everything is punitive. How about let's figure out how we can rehabilitate that landlord. So the the he's saying is he is just going to seize property and take
The mayor wanting to confiscate properties from bad landlords
SPEAKER_02it over, as opposed to figuring out what's the problem with these people, and we're gonna start from there. We're gonna see property. Ridiculous.
SPEAKER_06That's some scary stuff.
SPEAKER_03So yeah, um, I guess, you know, tell our listeners, Micah, they should get out there and fight and um speaking of fighting, so we just got a message saying the Arlington PD is knocking
Arlington PD knocking on doors after collecting names at city hall
SPEAKER_03on people's doors similar to what they're doing in New York. Um, and they're telling people that they were given a list of names and homes that were short term. So I guess they're trying to take those same same tactics here in Arlington.
SPEAKER_02So Yeah, so let the people know that you still live in the United States of America. If people come to your door, they need to have a warrant. Yeah. Don't be afraid that they're the police. They need to have a warrant. The best way, though, is not to engage with them. If you can avoid opening the door for them and them not recognizing that you're there, that's the best strategy. Because one of the things that happens when you open the door that you have to be especially confident in the ways that you deal with them because you are annoying human beings, right? They're just humans who think they have the authority and they will tell you anything. They will tell you anything to get the side. They are not your friends, they're not your friends. They are doing their job, and their job is to write as many
This is a revenue-generating shakedown, not public safety
SPEAKER_02things as possible and make as much money as possible. This for New York City is a revenue-generating operation. This is not, this is not about, don't think this is about making the city better in that in that respect, because they could have issues, they could issue things, and they could send you notices. They don't have to come, they can say, we have a issue wrong. Here is a warning, you fix it, and we'll be back. That's not what they're doing.
SPEAKER_06The shakedown.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's exactly what it is.
SPEAKER_06Well, thank you very, very much, Joy, for hopping on and and really opening our eyes and and and thank you for being in the forefront again of the fight. And uh we really appreciate that. Everybody Airbnb hosts everywhere appreciate that. Yeah. And um and any parting words you want to you want to say to our our listeners and um to uh yeah, any advice you got for them.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, so first of all, thank you so much for having me. I'd love to share the story to let people know what's happening. But the one thing I do think that people should do is really try to stay informed as to what's happening. Um and to try to put pressure on people. It is clear that the squeaky will get the oil, so you we need to be less fearful because if we tell us to bully, they just keep bullying, and that is what's happening.
SPEAKER_06Awesome advice. Awesome. Thank you so much, Joy. And um, we will share all your links on the show. You can get in contact with her directly if you'd like. I mean, if that's cool. And then um you could um yeah, check out the the fight H SAA. We'll we'll put the link on there for that.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and we'll be sharing it, um, letting people know about your guys' Facebook page as well, the HSA.
SPEAKER_02Well, thank you so much.
SPEAKER_06Oh, thank you for hopping on.
SPEAKER_02Thank you guys for for for telling the story often. We love to hear us sharing the story about home sharing.
SPEAKER_06Oh, yeah. We love home sharing. We're all on this together. Yes.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_06Alright, take care. Thank you.
SPEAKER_02You too. Bye-bye.
SPEAKER_06Bye-bye. That was Joy from the HSAA, the Home Sharing Association of America. There you go. And we just eye-opening stuff right there, man.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that was eye-opening. And it was funny as soon as she said that, we got that message saying that Arlington PD is knocking on people's doors, asking them if they have a short-term rental. Wow, man.
SPEAKER_06In America.
SPEAKER_03And I literally, and Mahogany asked the lady, hey, did you provide your contract tact information? And she said yes. Oh, at the meeting. At the city hall. Oh, that's I was like, that's why I was like, I'm good on that. Data collection is easy, man.
unknownDamn.
SPEAKER_06Just walked right into it. Yep. So, um, yeah, it's getting real out there, y'all. It's getting really real. And so I guess, you know, uh tune into we're a small part of this. Tune into us, you know, to if you want to try to stay abreast of the situation. And uh we'll do our best to get y'all the information, you know, you need. And we and we appreciate y'all listening to our show, and um we keep to we hope to keep pumping out some good good stuff for you. And um, yeah, man, get involved, fight the fight. Don't let them just roll us over like they've been trying to do. You know, it's your house, it's your property, you know, fight for it. I mean, that's I mean, if we don't have property in the United States, what the hell do we have?
SPEAKER_03Yeah. It's funny that you brought up the Fourth Amendment. That was I never thought about. You know, like them coming to your door. They can't come into your house. You have rights. So that was a really good point.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. Not that I'm gonna open the door when the police knock, anyways, Micah.
SPEAKER_03No, no, I don't. Not playing. Not playing, man. But uh, yeah, man. Uh keep living, keep letting, keep thriving. Um, this is episode 78. 78, man. We almost 22 away from 100, man.
SPEAKER_06We're right there, bro.
SPEAKER_03Man. We'll probably put something special together for that episode.
SPEAKER_06Cool.
SPEAKER_03But yeah, man, uh, thank y'all for listening. Check out our merchandise at uh live let thrive.com. Um, check out our YouTube page. We got all the videos coming soon. Uh check us out on Twitter, not Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram. Instagram definitely check out the Live Let Thrive page and the share button breakfast page. We're always dropping some good game on there, man.
SPEAKER_06We'll put all the links on there for you. You can find us. We're out there.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Live Let Thrive out. Thank you for tuning in to this week's episode of Live Let Drive. Be sure to tune in next week for all the latest in the world of Airbnb and all that entails. Bye bye.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Real Estate Rookie
BiggerPockets
Entrepremarriage
Myka & Mahogany
The Co-Living Show
Craig Curelop and Miller McSwain
BiggerPockets Real Estate Podcast
BiggerPockets
LEAN Podcast
Mahogany