Live Let Thrive Podcast
Airbnb, PadSplit, Corporate Rentals, Arbitrage, and Live Let Thrive cover all the creative ways to rent out your properties to maximize profits. We also cover creative ways to buy properties. Come along for the ride and have some fun along the way!
Live Let Thrive Podcast
Ep 196: Checking All The Airbnb Boxes for Maximal Exposure w Coach Cav!
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Coach Cav runs a turnkey short-term rental syndication across 202 properties in 35 markets - 175 investor-owned units managed under 36-month master leases. His secret: skip AirDNA, scroll Airbnb's filter checkboxes instead, then reverse-engineer which amenities the market lacks. A Calgary home sleeps 16, allows pets, has kid-friendly gear and a game room - Air DNA said price at $283, but as the only listing checking those boxes, it pulls $400+. The model grew from COVID-era arbitrage to a hundred investors in two years, layering VAs at one per eight properties for redundancy and partnering with Journey on larger portfolios.
Chapters cover Cav's value-gap analysis tool, why pets and EV chargers beat Wine bottles, how owner-occupancy regulations kill deals, the Newark boom after New York's four-million-listing purge, military planning frameworks adapted to STR ops, his upcoming Germany posting, and geopolitical resource plays. Tags span Coach Cav's company, unfiltered amenities, underdog markets like Montgomery and Enterprise Alabama, and the platforms guiding his national footprint.
Become a Live Let Thrive Insider: For $3 a month, get every new episode 5 days before everyone else. Raw, uncut, and early. Join here: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2641586/subscribe
Julie George's Million Dollar Host
STR mastermind: 140+ operators, 3 live calls a week. Code MYKA = 10% off your first payment.
Springboard to Wealth
Real estate mentorship with Thach Nguyen & Stephanie Owens: education, accountability, live events.
Real estate mentorship with Thach Nguyen & Stephanie Owens: education, accountability, live events.
Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.
Work with us. Interested in professional management or consulting?
Myka — Sharebnb: www.sharebnb.com
Steve — Argest Rentals: www.ArgestRentals.com
Sign up for PadSplit with Steve's link and get a free 1-on-1 PadSplit strategy call with Stevie Stacks: padsplit.com/hosts
Myka's other podcast, Entrepremarriage — building wealth without losing the marriage: youtube.com/@Entrepremarriage
All our links: linktr.ee/liveletthrive
#airbnb #airbnbhost #shorttermrentals #midtermrentals #padsplit #rentbytheroom #coliving #corporatehousing #BRRRR #realestate #realestateinvesting #VRBO #shareeconomy #airbnbsuperhost #airbnbpodcast #sharebnb #liveletthrive #liveletthrivepodcast #biggerpockets #directbookings #bookdirect #dfwrealestate
Cold open - Guestie for Hosts ad
SPEAKER_04Are you ready to run your short-term rental business like a super host? If so, look no further than Guestie for Hosts. Guestie for Hosts offers listing management for all three major OTAs, Airbnb, Booking.com, and Verbo. With Guestie for Host, you can create a branded direct booking website in minutes. I've been able to hit 61% direct bookings in my business and automate daily tasks such as communication with cleaners and communication with guests. Click the link in the show notes to get an additional $20 off your first month.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Live Let Thrive, a podcast about the Airbnb live, the share economy, and everything in between. Here are your hosts, Micah and Steve.
SPEAKER_03Hello, hello, hello. And welcome back to another exciting episode of Live Let
Coach Cav returns - 100 investors, 202 properties, 30 markets since 2021
SPEAKER_03Thrive.
SPEAKER_01What is up, Micah Man?
SPEAKER_04I'm good, Stevie Stacks. How you doing?
SPEAKER_01Good to be back from Mexico, man. Good to be back and yeah, podcasting again. Uh try to do some work over there a little bit as uh the internet sounds slow. So freaking slow, man. Makes it hard for a player. Um that was great when I was in playing Del Carmen. We'll see that you're at a freaking high-end hotel kind of thing.
SPEAKER_02Oh, the Airbnb.
SPEAKER_01Well, they got the wrong internet. Wherever I'm staying, they got the wrong internet. I'm looking into that. I'm trying to get us some good stuff. Anyway, oh yeah, they're they're laying down fiber optics right now, so it's gonna be okay. You you're a little too early, man. Right. So who's that? You ask? This is episode 196 of your favorite Airbnb VRBO, Home Alone Uber If Lyfts, uh, short-term rental podcast in the world, and we have a special guest, Micah. Who we got, Steve Coach Cav is back.
SPEAKER_03Second time around, let's go.
SPEAKER_01Second time around, man. A lot has changed in the world since Coach Cav first hopped on. Uh and we uh yeah, we're so happy to have you back, man. How you been? You need a oh, let me. I I saw an intro from your website. Is that thing still is that still good good to go?
SPEAKER_05Yes, uh which one there's two or three of us.
SPEAKER_01Coach Cav is an experienced real estate investor who specializes in building unique short-term rental Airbnb investments that operate the sharing economy, Airbnb, Peer Space, Turo, etc. Coach Cav is the owner of Your Space LLC, a company that manages your spaces, investor relationships, produces coaching programs and outreaches. Coach Cav is currently a modeling and simulations planner in the US Army. His life goal is to educate future investors and create opportunities for them. Sounds good. Oh still stands up. It works. I like you been, man. Good, good, busy, but good, right? Yeah, you hopped on about a year ago or so, or two years ago.
SPEAKER_05It was uh right after COVID. I think it was April, May ish 2020. So almost a year.
SPEAKER_04Is it me or is time just been flying by since COVID hit? Like it seems like weird.
SPEAKER_05I know it's weird. It's because we warped back into COVID too, right?
SPEAKER_01So we all yeah. So so how's uh how's your business changed since then?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, uh quite quite a bit. I think we've uh uh we've grown more into an investor model with the um uh a turnkey uh based investment program now that we we've been fortunate enough to bring in uh just about a 100 investors since uh the beginning of 2021 uh into different uh short-term rentals across 30 uh 30 plus markets. So it's been been quite quite the change, but uh a different level of responsibility to man, that sounds like y'all are man.
SPEAKER_04So basically you you run like an arbitrage syndication program, correct?
SPEAKER_05It it is a syndication
Syndication without the SEC filing - one investor per door, 36-month leases
SPEAKER_05without the steroids. Uh except uh investors in this case, they uh in most cases individually come into a unit. Uh so if it's 24 doors, you you typically have one investor for per door instead of an aggregated typical syndication model.
SPEAKER_04Okay, and do you need like the same public filings and all that as a regular uh real estate syndication or no?
SPEAKER_05No, it you know, a lot of it's in watching the wording. Uh and the the contracts that we do have, um, you know, we had to to send them through legal review to make sure that we were on the left side of what would otherwise be required to to have an SEC filing for for syndication efforts.
SPEAKER_04Okay. So let's say, hey, Coach Cav, I want to get a unit. Tell me what that process is like. How does how does how does your company step in and get me to that unit?
SPEAKER_05Right. So on the surface, we have a sourcing team that's looking across uh different markets across the US and Canada. We um we take on units administratively, meaning my company then goes out, uh, we sign uh long-term lease agreements or master lease agreements at a minimum of 36 months, which then creates the structure for 36-month investment period for investors. That uh then bleeds us into uh the design aspect. Once the investment's secured, uh we we provide all of the interior design and tech install with uh uh teams of interior designers that we've we've contracted, and then all uh of the back-end management stuff that's required to do your day-to-day stuff. So when you package that together, you get an investor that doesn't have to worry about any administrative overhead requirements, they don't have to worry about uh being legally permitted, insurance requirements, utilities, finding a place, negotiating with a landlord, don't have to worry about getting to a place to to design it, or you know, uh the leaky pipe at two in the morning. Uh so it really provides investors with with an opportunity to to get into the business without doing any of the the required work.
SPEAKER_01You know, you know what's interesting is just a few years back. I mean, I I remember hearing like bigger pockets, for example, when they first they started getting a little rumblings about the Airbnb world. And even like uh Brandon Turner on there was like, Man, you know, I don't get this Airbnb thing, it's so stupid. He goes, I I had I tried to make one of my rentals in Airbnb, and I get these calls. Uh, where's the train station or what time is the day? I don't know, look it up. You know, just like he's like annoyed by it. He goes, I don't understand it. I just I just want to get the rentals and and make them, you know, regular rentals and put someone in there for a year and be done with it. And it went from that sentiment to, of course, all the housing prices went crazy, right? And so people couldn't get the two percent rule no more, you know what I'm saying? Like two percent of the of what the price of the house is you're supposed to get in rent. People couldn't get the one percent, people couldn't get the half percent anymore. So now it's all gone like full circle to everybody wants an Airbnb. Everybody, even real estate investors are looking for a house that can be an Airbnb, and and it seems like you're riding the perfect wave at the perfect time when that happened.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, except for we we're not in the business of buying. Uh, that that's one unique difference here. Uh, everything's uh rental arbitrage, even in this model. So you know, as I mentioned, uh the fabric uh or the fabric of the structure is really creating uh uh those long-term lease agreements, which you know, for traditional homeowners creates uh stability for them in their investments, especially if they're uh a buying long-term hold investor. Uh that it that immediate partnership with long-term lease agreements provides them with instant stability to start to recoup their investment. Uh so uh that that structure, you know, again for us uh works because it allows us to get into uh as many homes across as many states without any restrictions, right? Uh, you know, we we've we've at times had uh 20 plus different projects being worked on at one time where you you you can't reasonably do that in uh a scenario where you're buying uh properties across multiple different
Convincing long-term landlords to hand over keys for master-lease arbitrage
SPEAKER_05states.
SPEAKER_01So maybe not, maybe not directly buying, but um it's working you you are working with the the previous model in a way, and it's changing because you're convincing people that are like that mindset. Like I'll never, you know, I'll never do Airbnb, just want to do long-term rentals. Yet you're convincing them to let your Airbnb out of their house. So it's it's changing where they're like, Oh, okay, so it's a different way to rent my house where I don't have to, you know, look up credit scores, look up background checks, and hopefully get a good renter in there for a year that's not gonna trash my place. Where Coach Cav and his team are gonna come in here and make my place freaking beautiful, like for a magazine, and they're gonna anything that's gonna break or whatever like that, they're gonna handle it immediately and keep it 100%. So the year or two years at least, whatever, when I get my house back, it's gonna look as pristine as it was when I handed it over, maybe even better.
SPEAKER_04Right. So, Coach, like how many units like how has your team gotten into? Like, how many units do you do you operate for all your operators?
SPEAKER_05So we we currently in a portfolio right now have uh 202 properties. Uh, of the 202, uh 175 uh belong to investors.
SPEAKER_04Wow. So okay, so now you're doing 175 belong to investors. Now now you just really blow my mind. Like, what does your team look like to manage all this?
SPEAKER_05Uh so it's multi-layered. Uh if if it's a large investment, we've we've partnered with larger uh management companies, uh, more specifically Journey. Uh so anything over five units that we take, uh, we're handing it off to Journey to manage. Uh they provide all of the back-end management that's required for uh for any any short-term rental operation. Uh for anything less than that, we we've got a layered system where we uh we have our team of VAs uh that that grow uh one per eight property, we bring VAs in. And then we go out and we we source experience host uh to come in and and manage properties on the surface, and then they uh the VAs provide them with back-end support so they can focus on uh the guest and the customer experience, and the VAs focus on all the back and admin stuff that may have to go on with Airbnb and whatnot.
SPEAKER_01So it you know, it's it jumps out at me when you're saying that the the especially the part with one VA per eight properties, right? It sounds it sounds like you're bringing a little bit of the the military mentality and structuring your business. Is that correct? Because you got your platoons, your squadrons, and all that stuff, but you got you know a leader for each one. And is that correct?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, that that that's interesting because the being in a military, you know, it it helps because we we go through this planning process, it's called MDMP or the military decision-making process, and uh it's built on the premises that everything's a problem, but in order to solve a problem, you've got to sort of build a framework around it. Um, and then you've got to understand, uh, understand the problem. Uh, and then you break it down into different or subsets of different categories that then allow you to uh you know create the the best case scenario uh to to uh to define success, right? Um, but yeah, you're you're exactly right. The everything that that's sort of built out is it it's it's it's due to you know my background and and what we what we do on a day-to-day basis, and it's been able just to translate over into uh into business.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I like that. Because that's um we're at the point right now, you know. My company, we we hit we have um over 40 units now, right? So we that we have as our own arbitrages plus the ones we manage for other people, but we have and I and that's crossed my mind before. I'm like, well, we should once like every one every 10 units or whatever, put just uh you know, don't want to overwhelm the VAs, you've just they're gonna manage those 10, then the next one to manage. I thought about doing something like that. We haven't done that yet, so they're all doing all of the units, so but that's that's pretty cool, man. As I'm gonna look into that, yeah. Thank you for that insight.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, so so some of it was was math, right? Because you you'll interview and you'll hire, and the first thing they'll tell you normally is like they'll they'll take on up to 14 or 15 properties, right? And then you're just kind of like, yeah, you know, you get all that work out of one person, but uh at some point, right, they they have a capacity. And then if you don't layer them with redundancy, uh then you you may create a failure point in your business where life happens, right? VA gets sick or mom gets sick, something happens, and then they're out for a couple days, and then you've got to find a way to fill that gap. So when we peeled that back, it led us to uh the the eight property rules. So then we're able to layer um uh them with what some redundant operations behind
24-hour VA coverage with four-hour overnight gaps unless late check-in
SPEAKER_05them.
SPEAKER_01So explain that layer layer them with redundancy. That sounds interesting.
SPEAKER_05So so so normally as I mentioned, you know, you'll get one and they'll take on up to 15 or 16 properties. So we we we could have played the one to 16 rule, but you know, the the one to 16 rule then lends you to risk, right? Because if life happens, then you create uh a hole in the business that uh could have been prevented if you had uh two fulfilling right that that uh that role. So we we've we've got two covering essentially 16 properties versus one covering 16 properties, right? So it just creates a layer of redundancy, uh just in case you know one's out for some odd reason, or you're breaking up into to different shifts to have you know somewhat of a 24-hour coverage.
SPEAKER_04Okay, so two covers 16. If one goes out, they're base essentially they're covering eight, but then one goes out, he has the 16. Okay, I got you. Because that's one hiccup I'm kind of concerned about too. Like I have one VA, but if he goes down sick, oh man, what do I do? Okay, that's a good okay, gotcha.
SPEAKER_05Because they already come in with that capacity, right? To to do six, so you just break it up, yeah. Then if you have to rely on that one just for two or three days, then you know they've got the capacity to do it.
SPEAKER_04And you said your VAs are on a 24 by seven rotation, 24-7 rotation, yeah.
SPEAKER_05Uh no, there's about uh there's about a four-hour window or so overnight where uh nobody's on.
SPEAKER_04So okay.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01And that hasn't presented any problems having that again.
SPEAKER_05No, so the the the the the the thing is if if there's a reservation, uh when when we get the end of the day report, it comes in about 10 o'clock. If there's somebody that's checking in later, uh, you know, if they say, hey, we're not coming until 2 a.m., then somebody will stay up to cover that. Uh if we don't have someone coming in uh that late at night, then there's no reason, you know, for us to uh to uh to have somebody staying up just monitoring, uh monitoring chat.
SPEAKER_04You know, you're the second straight guess. So people basically, what do y'all are doing is um when everyone's checked in, everything's all good, everyone kind of backs off for the night. That's basically how y'all run it.
SPEAKER_05Right. But uh I I guess because we we get a we get a detailed EO end of the day report by by 10 by 10 p.m. Their last messages go out, uh, ask if there are any check-ins that haven't checked in yet. They find out exactly what time they're coming in. Um so that then prompts someone to to stay on and cover at least until you know the last check-in has has occurred. But otherwise, you know, we we we cut swing load at least for uh for four to five hours. But the the four to five hours our time is still normal daylight operating time uh in Asia, right? So even though we have folks that are off, there's still some coverage that that's happening uh while we sleep.
SPEAKER_04Okay, that makes sense then. Okay, now now because I remember you you said earlier that you you source leads from US to Canada. Where are your listings at?
SPEAKER_05Oh, they're they're in about 35
Sourcing 35 markets from Sask to Calgary - proximity to Banff at $400 a night
SPEAKER_05different markets. Uh we're in two provinces in Canada, uh Skat and uh Calgary, Alberta.
SPEAKER_04Oh, okay. I'm in I'm in uh what is it, Edmonton? No, I forget. I forgot. I'm I have some up there. Uh the market. I've been forgetting it. Uh Canmore Banff, Banff, that area.
SPEAKER_05Banff, okay, yeah. So we're we're not too far from there. Uh the the home we took in Calgary was uh only due to its proximity to that that resort. Right. We've got a uh we've got a shuttle not too far from from the uh the home that we have there that goes uh directly to to Bayneth in less than an hour. Uh but the the the the little unknown secret to that that park and the the travelers that go there, uh they pay a lot of money for uh for travel there. So we we see over $400 a night in a five-bedroom home that sleeps 16 uh in Calgary.
SPEAKER_01Wow. Yeah. Oh no, that's that's great, man. That's great money.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah. See, that that makes it like like how do you um how are you sourcing your markets? Like, hey, this I know this will be investor friendly. Are you mainly chasing just vacation rental markets or you just loading up air DNA and going where they say, or how are you guys sourcing it?
SPEAKER_05No, so so a lot of it, a lot of it comes with uh uh my my my my lead uh guy harper. He's he's uh he's in the real estate, but he's also a sales guy. Uh so he he monitors markets based on one regulations and then two uh saturation of markets. So he he's he's not looking in Houston, right? Uh but so so he's he's looking in sort of mid mid-tier markets, right? And then the the third uh is our military markets, right? Just because of uh what what what's created in those environments and the travel demographics that come out of it. Uh but that that's that's where he uh builds the uh the list to to start to source uh uh units and locations. And then obviously some like the Calgary deal uh was largely based on uh the the other resort town of Banaf out there that you you mentioned earlier.
SPEAKER_01So what tools does your partner use to find the these places?
SPEAKER_05Airbnb.
SPEAKER_01That's it. He don't use AirDNA, he don't pay for any special something like software like that, just straight Airbnb.
SPEAKER_05Nope, nope, Airbnb. Um and the reason why is because Airbnb gives you the most real time, up to date. If you go in as a traveler and you need market, uh you you'll you'll just you'll you'll get the facts, right? Without a 12-month lag or six-month lag uh in data. So it you know, it it helps us understand on the surface within minutes of uh what the market and what the market's potential is.
SPEAKER_04That's a smart idea, man. Because you gotta you start pinning out air DNA, and they you know, it's it's data, but you know, you know, I see a lot of a lot of quirks with their DNA, you know, a lot of flaws.
SPEAKER_01You've seen them too, Micah, right? Yeah, so like so like let's just say, for example, you look at this resort town with um, and you look up three-bedroom, two-bath house, and it's saying they should be all getting the thousand bucks or they should all get 500 bucks a night, right? Or whatever it is, and then you put it and then you punch in a four-bedroom house, and it says it's so it should only get a hundred bucks a night. And you're like, why would a four-bedroom house make less than a three-bedroom house? And then you go in because there's more three bedrooms out there, more data for them to pull. Whereas there's only like two or three four bedrooms that have, you know, you know, or that are pretty crappy properties that aren't making very much. So Air DNA, the computer mind says, Well, four four bedroom properties do should do way less than three-bedroom properties. And it's just it's just it's not looking at it like uh like like you said, you go to air the Airbnb, you see right away, oh, it's a four-bedroom, but it's a crappy property, you know, it's got carpet everywhere, it's got old old wall, nasty furniture, you know. And so I I I could that's a good, that's uh that's a the biggest tip so far. I mean, you give us some good stuff, but um, so how how does could you walk us through how your partner does that? You know, how how they look how they scroll Airbnb to find these these nuggets of of knowledge.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, so so we have uh built what we we we we coin is a value gap analysis tool it's just an excel data sheet uh it's broken up into three sections the travel demographics the the the value gaps which are really the the amenities and then the far right column shows
Value-gap analysis - traveler demographics, amenity gaps, unique-value positioning
SPEAKER_05us what unique value is in the market uh so the traveler demographics are you know the most important thing regardless of the market because you've got to understand who's traveling and what the market's capacity is uh for those travelers uh then the the most important or second most important thing become uh the the the amenity gaps or the value gaps as we call them and that's where going into Airbnb really helps you understand right uh where your value potential is in the market because as you mentioned Steve uh air DNA will give you sort of baseline numbers but in Airbnb by just going into a very filtered search right I can find out that if I sleep 14 to 16, uh I may be the only home that can then have the ability to offer pets, have a kit-friendly listing, offer games, and I can you know then I can see how many spas are are in the market and then have the potential to add that. So once we understand where those gaps exist in the market, we then you know within that data sheet we have a very targeted result that comes out of it that we you know hand to the interior designer and say hey here's here's where this place needs to be but what that gets us to is then figuring out the the unique value portion uh is where when you compete with less than 5% of the market uh for any one travel demographic. So for example the the place in Calgary sleep 16 uh it it allows pets it has kid friendly amenities we put a dedicated game room uh in there and it's the only home in Calgary that close to Bayniff that has those unique amenities offered. So AirDNA right for instance told us to price at 283 a night but our value in the market told us that we're not competing with anyone so we're gonna set the market price here and we price it right above 400 bucks a night. Ooh I love that you said you hit a uh couple of you said value gap analysis and amenity gap now man i love that like what are amenities are you saying that aren't readily available in most markets that someone could go out right now and create a value automatically uh pets are are probably the biggest one uh because most people they they feel uh if they don't have pets they probably won't allow pets in their short term rental uh so so pets become one of the bigger discriminators but you know to me that's that's just like Walmart not selling um you know groceries right why why would they discriminate in the business uh that would affect their bottom line that's just people being emotionally tied to to uh to their business when when they shouldn't be uh so normally when when you're adding pets uh it it will push you above half the market uh automatically uh kid friendly listings are another big one uh we we find huge gaps in
Pets and kid-friendly boxes eliminate half the competition instantly
SPEAKER_05every market when it comes to kid friendly amenities and and the key here becomes if if it's a filterable item inside of Airbnb or VRBO then you should look at it from a uh a listing build standpoint because it gives you uh the unique ability to then offer something against a certain travel demographic that others uh don't offer and you know we always get into this conversation about you know being on the first page and uh and and showing showing up in the rankings but you know at the end of the day it's never where you start it's where you finish because every traveler has a unique travel need and they're gonna go in and uh start to select filters. So if you show up on the first page when no filters are selected uh good for you but you know nine times out of 10 people are looking for something specific so that's where you want to be right you want you want to be there when uh all the filters are are up and you're you're competing now with with less than you know uh you're competing with a lot a smaller portion of the market at that point more of those boxes that are checked man the more valuable you are that is a fact right there uh my vacations yeah I always hit that swimming pool box I want to swim pool man there you go that's it now now let's say you're doing a a market analysis because I've never actually really done that just went in there and checked all the boxes and just see hey how many listings check all the boxes are you guys one of those listings that checks all the boxes or check or you guys check the boxes that aren't readily available it depends on the market so so so downtown Houston has a different travel demographic than down in Webster uh so we're looking at different things or different amenities to offer for for those two distinctly uh uh unique places got you okay and we had uh someone that hopped on the show a long a while back mica ah with airs is that her or abear i don't know the one that north upstate new york oh abor yeah abor yeah and she is she she decided to put the the it it told her the the info told her to put the hot tubs at each of the her spots right her little cabins at her her rate area you know she could charge way more her bookings went through the roof just for that one thing and that's special that's special up there because it gets cold and people want to be able to chill out in the hot tub and that makes a huge difference so but would a hot tub work in Houston maybe not so much you know rap videos who knows but but um but yeah I like I like that how you said it depends on the the amenity depends on the area you know so I can imagine up in Canada cold and snow put a put a hot tub out on the balcony i mean that's gonna be a big sell you know down south or the on the coast you want a nice swimming pool that's gonna be a huge sell right it just depends on the area yeah yeah because like remember I I was going through Houston because I I was dealing with the oversaturation so I was like man what's something that they don't have and it it was it was Tesla chargers it's four houses in Houston with Tesla chargers I'm like man y'all got all these Tesla in the road and ain't nobody got no Tesla chargers I was like there you go there so yeah it definitely depends on that market for sure are you wanted to hop into the short-term rental space but just don't know where to get started join our Live Let Thrive Facebook group to network with other like minded investors we have property managers lenders and other experienced hosts to learn from click the link below to join I'll see you there yep that's a good point uh uh Hebba uh one of our interior designers she also manages uh a few of her places uh she just ordered um um a Tesla charger for the a garage in one of the places in Houston so she's she's only two she was listening to Liverlet Thrive I bet oh yeah Hebba's a friend of the show man we had oh that was Hebba never mind there you go yeah we're in the same mastermind yeah yeah heaven knows yeah that's the truth heaven knows that should be her her tagline I like that oh man that is cool man and so um you you you bring people in and you coach them too how does the coaching part of your business work uh so i you know i like to say i don't
Coaching through investor calls and live deal overviews
SPEAKER_05i don't do much coaching right uh a lot of it just it's because uh i take quite a few phone calls for investors that are interested and then you know a lot of it just turned into to to coaching them into understanding right uh the the difference between them doing something themselves or us uh doing it for them um and then on our live calls uh with each investment deal you know those are essentially uh investment overviews but also coaching sessions as well because investors then get a chance to to ask you know all the questions they uh they have in mind about short-term rentals and our philosophies and and and the investment that's in front of it so uh I think you're like a a lead by example kind of guy it a quote comes to mind and I'll butcher the quote you know it's something like it was talking about in the old olden days he goes uh they told this one this one guy see I don't even remember the name so I'm terrible at this but he says go out and spread the gospel and then the second part of that is and if only if absolutely necessary you should speak and I was like that's cool man you know go out there you're showing like just by being you know who you are showing this is how it should be done and you said yeah you don't really coach but all these things you're telling us today that's some that's some major knowledge. Yeah yeah a lot of it just comes from experience uh over time and uh I I think being spread out in so many different markets really lends itself to uh having to to uniquely understand what what could work in one market that won't work in another market. Uh and especially because we have an investor based model now uh it it is more important now than ever that we get the the market research right and then because we don't put any uh administrative liability on our our investors like we hold the leases to all these uh all these places that we have so we we've got to be comfortable in our model in our analysis to say that you know if an investor decides to park the car on the side of
Most overrated amenity - anything without an Airbnb checkbox
SPEAKER_05the road and say look I'm done you know tomorrow uh we we've got to be okay taking that investment back into our portfolio and uh and knowing that it'll perform based on the market research so now a question uh what's what's one of the can you talk about you know value ads and uh amenities stuff like that what's one of the most overrated ones that you've seen that that people always try oh if I leave a bottle of wine it's gonna bring it up or if I do this I do that what's one of the most overrated ones that doesn't really pay a lot of dividends that you've noticed anything that doesn't have a block next to it that you can check oh oh I like that as a fact it's gotta check a box right it's gotta check a box uh because I mean if you think about it that means the the platforms deem it important enough right to to have it as a a filterable item so but let's let's think about the the gaming market and how much that's grown right that was not a filterable item uh this time last year on any major platform and now it is so the folks that offered games uh last year uh they may have had value offered but it wasn't a searchable value which means they couldn't you know charge more for it or stand out in the market but now you can uh because you can go in and check check the block and then you can show the photo and then have it tagged in your summary and now you've got sort of the the the three layer um uh the three layer monster to to uh to show the potential guest Airbnb does the research for you basically you just gotta follow yes there you go that's it i couldn't say that any better they they do it for you because it's right in front of you right you just gotta follow it this that should be your your tagline coach cav check the blocks check the blocks it's simple right but it it is it's you know it's it's right there in front of me wow so install a swimming pool a hot tub install i just go down the list oh man so where so where where is your business headed man y'all gonna get like a thousand units coming up uh i i don't know we we we just finished 24 down in uh san antonio heba did did a phenomenal job leading that effort uh with with a team of uh of remote heroes that she managed for uh for almost a month on the ground um but you know we're we're continuing just to build the investor network uh still looking across different markets and and starting to build uh a little bit more of the back end uh the back end out uh but the big picture the the the sharing economy I know we talked about it last time but uh we we are actively searching well we're actively expanding the RVs
Montgomery, Enterprise Alabama, Newark post-New York purge - hot small markets
SPEAKER_05that are in the portfolio currently three and then we're actively looking for an RV part uh that we can we can take and really uh encompass that sharing economy uh model into to one one footprint so hopefully we we find the right deal out there that that uh gets us to to a home run I like though so uh and if if you don't mind give us some some trade secrets what are some cities that you're real big on right now but you heard you mentioned San Antonio yeah so I I think um Montgomery Alabama um enterprise Alabama uh and I'm talking all these small smaller markets that folks are gonna be like what what is he talking about um another uh great market that we've we we've gotten into the the new newark market and it's uh largely because the regulations came in in New York uh you had four million listings that went away overnight uh post-COVID which then uh now made newark the the gateway to New York City right so if you're close to Penn Station in Newark then you you are now getting New York City prices uh in Newark uh so uh those would be the three markets I I think uh we we've experienced like uh the most growth in and in a lot of a lot of good numbers gotta love Alabama man because that's when nobody's gonna look there I'm in a few markets that I know ain't nobody gonna ever look there they don't think people go there I'm like okay so yeah I love that strategy uh uh I want to hear the you're saying that when y'all search out for new new cities or new locations and you had mentioned it regulations now and and you showed us an example because that that makes Newark so strong because they they took four million listings off of the New York or whatever um so how what do you look for in a city's regulation do you look for a city that already has existing Airbnb regulations or do you go for a city you that has zero regulations or how do you do that so so the regulations um the the way we look at them it's not a bad thing right because it gives you a roadmap to success uh and if it's not too restrictive uh we we'll go for it so for example uh Nashville Charleston and Savannah I I think they had an overnight meeting some time ago and they built these regulations that almost prohibit uh outside investors from buying or renting up multiples of properties uh and not living there so so the first thing we look for in the regulations is if it's an owner occupied right regulation because that will start to limit your capacity and then uh even if you get into the market it's going to require the homeowner to be liable in some respect and then most of them don't want to sign up for it.
SPEAKER_01So it becomes increasingly harder to get into regulated markets that have an owner occupied um uh ordinance yeah okay so as long as it it you like some regulation but owner occupied is a deal killer you don't you ain't you ain't trying I mean because you the the owners basically have to trust what you're doing enough to uh to to hold some liability in the deal right and most of them uh trust me they they'll they'll they they may like the model but they they'll be like uh you know no no thanks you know I don't want to sign up for that okay so what about what about places um that have zero regulations you don't fear like going heavy into one of those spots and all of a sudden overnight they're gonna start throwing some regulations no because what we've seen is they don't they don't shut it down they they um they they find a way to to grandfather in uh current listings um in a way that you know uh allows you to to uh to to continue to operate i think we're we're starting to see that in Charlotte like right now uh but uh a lot of what they're doing in in most cases are are are largely revolved around taxes right and not so much killing short-term rentals because they've you know brought the the city to its knees so uh yeah it it doesn't stop us from from going out into to different different areas that don't have regulations i i guess me and me and mica are gun shy in that regard because we were operating out of Arlington Texas where they shut down Airbnb in like 99% of the houses in Arlington just totally shut it down not even owner occupied nothing nobody grandma can't rent out the back you know little two one bedroom house in the backyard everybody got shut down with no way of doing it except if you're in one little one mile radius outside of the cowboy stadium you can do Airbnb so that's we're gun shy in that regard and I hear what you're saying that if they have you know usually they're more reasonable uh we just were fortunate enough to see the unreasonable part jerry Jerry Jones and his boys you know wanted to take it all over anyways that's a different subject altogether I will say this about those regulations it has created a heavy heavy opportunity uh you know I just had the duplex in the entertainment district we ended up not closing on it but it does create unique opportunities where if you are in the entertainment district you have a little huge and and you're you're dealing with the small circumference of people and then like how coach Kev says that value adds there you can find out what they aren't offering in a very easy manner because it ain't too many hosts if you stand out there it's a killer definitely creates opportunity but I I guess my my thing was what if he would have done it before that one mile radius thing saying oh Arlington's doing pretty good there's not a lot of Airbnbs no regulations I'm gonna just get one about two miles away from the stadiums I'll be good and he would he would they would all got shut down. You know what I'm saying? I'm just saying that I'm I'm trying to see what you're looking for when you go into a city with no regulations.
SPEAKER_05Yeah I mean the risk is there I and I I guess that's just part of you know the the risk we take on in in in this business uh with that potentially happening in in any market right so I don't know that uh I don't know that there's the right answer to to to that you know particular scenario.
SPEAKER_01I I guess the the other end of it like if you did see a city that already has existing you know Airbnb rules that you thought were not too unfair and then that would give you a roadmap to get in there and say okay we can operate here and make money here and and pay the taxes no problem.
SPEAKER_05Yeah I mean the other side of it too is you you have so many legal operators and people that don't want to do the hard work right to get permitted uh it the regulations will eventually
Houston's unregulated chaos - half the market would fold under permitting
SPEAKER_05cause markets to to level right uh at some point uh and and let's just let's just use Houston for example right uh houston if Houston drew up uh regulations uh because you have so many people that just get in because either they're being sold something you know an expiring lease or you know somebody told them it was a good idea uh the those aren't the people that are gonna uh go through with regulating in most cases right uh uh their place right it's gonna be the the the professional host and the serious operators that are building looking to build a business in most cases like like us right and uh my my guy harper uh if we're putting more than uh four to five properties in any one area uh he's also reaching out to the Chamber of Commerce and uh the city council to uh one meet and greet understand where they are uh from a regulatory standpoint and then just let him ask them about opportunities that we could potentially have with our short terms and in the market so it's sort of a layered conversation there but uh you know the the in my in my estimation uh half half the Houston market would be uh out within a year if they were to regulate uh anything uh in in that market yeah it needs regulation they got mad at me for saying it yeah Houston used to be a great market right for uh for prime uh airbnbs and short term rentals but you know it's just become a breeding ground for as I call it you know hey who wants to who wants a lease right and sell selling lease yeah they were they were ready to burn me at the stake for saying that those who bad at me these regulations right yeah Houston's like one giant suburb right yeah that's it's crazy man Yeah, we still have a ton of listings out there.
SPEAKER_04But oh, let's go into this. So how are you dealing with the saturation out there?
SPEAKER_05Good. I mean, the look, we we're we're not operating, in my estimation, right, with the the the satur saturated part of the market, right? All those one bedroom and uh two bedroom places that are in the market, uh, we're we're not necessarily competing with them because they didn't do any market research and analysis priority
Not competing with good-idea operators - only with research-backed hosts
SPEAKER_05going into the market, right? They if you're operating on a good idea, we're not competing with you because you know we we've done some due diligence to help us understand where we can uh attain some degree of success in in the market.
SPEAKER_04I like that. If you're operating on a good idea, we're not competing with you. I love that.
SPEAKER_01Plus, it's checking all the blocks too. A lot of people aren't checking all the blocks.
SPEAKER_05Checking the blocks, man. Checking the blocks. When I leave here, right? Check all the blocks.
SPEAKER_01So so how so you keeping your your day job, and your day job is being in the military. Thank you for your service and all that. How how much longer do you plan on staying in the military?
SPEAKER_05I don't know, man. I I've got a pretty fun job. I I play games for a living. Oh as a simulations guy, uh, I build games uh so you know soldiers can uh train you know in the simulated environment before they go out and do it in real life. So I I have a ton of fun doing what I do. Uh we're getting ready to head to Germany uh here this summer. Uh I'll be there for three years. So next time uh in two years we we talk again on the podcast, we'll have a six-hour time difference or a seven-hour time difference. But man, you going to Germany for three years, man? Yes.
SPEAKER_04Whoa, congratulations.
SPEAKER_01I I think you happy about that.
SPEAKER_05Oh, yeah, yeah. You know, it'll be a good family, uh family trip. And you know, some of it's just uh around the fact that you know we'll we'll get a chance to break some of the cultural norms that we were closed right here within this 50 state capacity with. And you know, one of the things people don't really understand about Europe is that uh they're so close to other countries, and every country is a different culture, whereas like we cross state lines and uh some people may say, I'm from Florida, I'm different, I'm from Alabama, I'm different, but like the hell you are. You know, we we are what we are here in this 50 state capacity, but you know, it's just different when you go to Italy, to France, to to the Netherlands, to to Germany, and and all those different countries that are uh you know in the same geographical capacity as we travel across the uh the states. So I'll get off uh my Europe bubble because I know I love Europe too, man.
SPEAKER_01I love Europe.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, Steve's a traveler, man. Steve's been everywhere.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you drive a couple miles and you're a whole different country, different language, you know. It's it's crazy, man. You in in one day you could be in like five or six different countries, it's insane. Um, but that is cool, man. I'm I'm happy for you. I always I'd always you know fantasize about some cool like that, taking the family to another place for a year, you know, just getting them a different culture, a different, you know, site, different view on life. I love that.
SPEAKER_05Right, right, right, yeah.
SPEAKER_01So you your business can run itself while you're gone.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I mean for me, like I I do a lot of the the um the admin overhead stuff, you know, and as I say, just investor relations. So if it pertains to the the the structure of release agreement that the company's gonna sign, uh, or investors that are looking uh to spend you know fifty thousand dollars or more on an investment, then um I'm I'm taking on uh I'm taking the lead on those. But otherwise, you know, we've got an operation team operations team that handles a lot of the uh day-to-day stuff.
SPEAKER_01So so if you don't mind me asking, and right now it's all over the news, the the Ukraine thing. And you know, you're going to Germany and I automatically thought of the Ukraine situation. What do you think? How do you think all that's gonna unfold?
SPEAKER_05Um, I don't know. Uh to to be honest with you, I
Ukraine invasion, resource dependency, and short-term rental non-impact
SPEAKER_05think uh the the timing is rather uh interesting uh as to where where we are uh politically with uh the G7 countries and and all these countries now being uh in the midst of of an election year, right? Uh when Putin uh decides to to go in and invade. Um but you know, as far as the the resources that uh the Ukraine has, what what I do understand, at least from a uh uh a resource standpoint, they're a top five resource country. So the the the taking over of resources to combine them with you know it's kind of like Walmart taking, you know, uh a publics, right? Uh now you you hold more resources, which makes the world uh in Europe more dependent upon the resources that you hold. So so then that gives you more leverage, right? Uh so uh if that's the end state uh to to his game, then you know what we're gonna be in for uh for for a rocky ride.
SPEAKER_04Whoa. Now that's a good question. Because I now I've been to Airbnb groups, and a lot of people they're like saying, Yeah, this is gonna affect us. Like, do you think it could have it's gonna have an effect? A lot of people saying it's gonna have an effect on the housing, which then in turn affects us. Where do you think those effects do do fall?
SPEAKER_05I I don't think they'll I mean they'll they'll have economic impacts, but not in the housing and short-term rental uh market.
SPEAKER_04Okay, yeah. Interesting.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it is a it is an interesting take because I was you know, I haven't I've I've seen the headlines, I haven't really read too much into it, but uh when you when you explain it like that, you know, it's a top five resource country. I was like, why does everybody care about you know about this so much? And I you know, it's sorry if it's a callous question, you know, it's Russia, you know, going in on their neighbor, whatever you know, Russia's whatever. Um, but I was like, that makes a lot more sense. There's a lot of economic interest in in this country, that's why. And for Europe, more than probably more than us, but that's why everybody's attention's focused there. Where if they would have, you know, went in and took over Uzbekistan or something, and the world would be like, ah, whatever. Go ahead and have them. But yeah, that that's yeah, follow the money, right?
SPEAKER_05Yep, that's it. Become resource rich, and you know, you the the world uh uh has a dependency on you.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, sorry to get deep with a question like that, but but we got coach cavard, man. We gotta ask him anything, right? Oh man, well, thanks for hopping on, dude. This is cool. I love how your business is growing. I love how you got the singular focus. I love how you're checking all the boxes, checking all the the blocks. You know, that's this. I mean, this is some it's it's simple. Some of it is simple like that. Check the boxes, it's right there in front of you. You know, like you said, uh you before uh you know, there was no box for gaming, so why even bother you know building something out that's not going to give you any, you know, front page uh SEO? But once that box popped up, okay, throw some games in there, man. And uh, I love that your value, the pets, kid friendly. Oh man, that's that those are two huge things.
SPEAKER_04If someone wants to invest in Airbnbs with you, where would they reach you at coach?
SPEAKER_05Uh they they can text uh into our turnkey community uh by uh texting the the word club or turnkey to 202-918-5027. Uh, that'll pull them into our uh turnkey text-based community, and that's where we share uh all of our uh upcoming investment opportunities uh that we we also host uh live calls on every Wednesday.
SPEAKER_04Okay, cool. I might have to text into that. Turnkey. All right, man. But yeah, man, thank you for coming on. It's been great having you, man. Those value ads checking all the boxes. You probably the only person on here that's actually came in there and broke it down like that. You know, most people are trying to use air DNA, just use Airbnb.
SPEAKER_05Oh yeah, air DNA will get you in trouble, man. I mean, it builds a false sense of of market security when you know, in fact, they they can't really tell you the value that your place will hold, right? At the end of the day, and your your value
Wheelhouse graphs show sub-10% amenity gaps at a glance
SPEAKER_05lies in what the market's not offering. So, you know, my my Calgary example, if if I'm the only show in town that's you know, sleeping 16 with uh offer pets and kid-friendly amenities, and what why would I charge 283 when you know I'm the only show in town, you know? So uh, but that that's the air dna follower that then places you know the uh their nightly rate at 283 instead of at 400 bucks.
SPEAKER_04So yeah, you know what? If Air DNA is listening to this, they're probably gonna have those start creating those checkboxes inside of their uh algorithm, which would be smart if they did, but yeah.
SPEAKER_05Uh I mean just follow Airbnb's lead is you know what I tell all all of the the developers that that call and and ask about you know the some of the things we're doing, just you know, look look at Airbnb and and what they're saying to their audience, uh, but but all of it's it's filterable, right? So uh there you go. The answers right there from it.
SPEAKER_01You know that bring it back to a military thing, man. It's like it I don't know if this even ties in, you know. You know how me. I go way out there and I try to bring it all back in, but um I I forgot what this what this um what this phenomenon is called. I was even trying to look it up right now. But back in World War II, you know, they send out planes, some planes will come back, some wouldn't, you know what I'm saying? And then they the ones that came back had bullet holes in them, and so the the the experts at the time saying, Well, let's put some where these bullet holes are hitting, let's put some armor right there to reinforce these areas where they're getting hit. And it took like this guy who to think of it differently, right? And he's like, No, he goes, The ones that are coming back with bullet holes, that means the bullet holes aren't those those spots aren't taking down the plane. We need to reinforce the spots that aren't getting hit by bullets, and that made me think of the air DNA saying, Well, yeah, let's reinforce to where the bullet holes are. You know, here's the data, go, you know, do this. But you're looking at where the bullet holes aren't hitting, you know, and out and using uh Airbnb to do so. So I don't know if that analogy made any sense, but I that's it reminded me of.
SPEAKER_05No, and just just for everybody else, so uh wheelhouse also offers the same amount of uh data points that uh Airbnb does, they give it to you a little differently in a graph chart. But uh if you go into wheelhouse and you look at uh a specific market, uh they they've got a graphical depiction that shows you uh by percentage what the market's offering. So if we're if we're ever looking at something real quick uh to to provide some feedback on, uh we we just pop into wheelhouse and look at pull the market up, look at the the chart, and it tells us exactly where the gaps are uh in in the market. So anything that's you know 10 or under that's that's not being offered, then you you there there you go. It's it's a decision point that gets us quickly to say you know yes on on a uh a particular market or listening.
SPEAKER_04Oh that's good. I know Willhouse is doing that.
SPEAKER_01I know it's a lot cheaper than air DNA. Yeah, well, you got a free version too, so yeah.
SPEAKER_04I noticed these pricing, these pricing companies are starting to hop into the data space, you know. Price labs is one of them as well. So I mean, you guys are pricing it out, you might as well have the data to back it up, you know.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, yeah, cool, drive decisions, yeah. Well, cool, Coach Cav, thanks again for hopping on. Two-time guests, and I guess maybe the next time you hop on, you'll be in Germany. So yeah, Tonka Shay. I don't know if that's oh cool. Well, you it's always a great having you on, you're always welcome back. Um, you already said working, folks, fine. You right? And cool, man. Well, thank you so much, and and good luck and all and all your endeavors.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah, we are out later. That was a good episode, man. Episode 196. So that means what by the time April 1st rolls around, we'll have 200 episodes out there, man. But uh, yeah, I want to thank y'all. Thank y'all for continuing to listen to us, man. This has been awesome, man. I just learned a lot. Like, I've been I've been over here on my laptop checking boxes and seeing what's not available in some of the markets, especially Houston, because yeah, that shit's oversaturated.
SPEAKER_01Shoot, yeah, man. Oh, that's a great episode. Like I said, it's like it's not it, and it's funny, and and people look at things, look, try to make things so complicated, right? It's not brain surgery. It he just said he just said the simplest things, you know. Uh, allow pets, make it kid friendly. I mean, he named some simple things and check the box as many boxes as you can, yep, and and you'll be successful, of course. You know, be in the right area with the the regulations thing, but he didn't make it like brain science, like people like uh I'll bring it up, you know. The thing with the with the Silicon Valley guys, those are oh, what is with air DNA? This this is we need to find this perfect, you know, area because because Air DNA says they're basing everything on that, which could be flawed information, right? Yeah, and it's not and if amenities weigh so heavily on what a place is going to be successful, air DNA ain't telling you all that. No, so so, anyways, yeah, man, just um make a place like I like he said, make it a value-friendly place that offers amenity the good amenities for that area, and you'll be fine.
SPEAKER_04That's a fact, man. That that was that was a that was I was typing in some stuff. That was good, that was a really good, really good episode and a really good gym because that that's something uh you know I haven't really done. And what I did was I just went and checked all the boxes and see who actually has it. But Airbnb, I noticed something about it. They would show me listings that don't have the amenities, but just check the amenity off, saying, Oh, by the way, it's missing an EV charger. So it's like, hmm.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. They because they want more, they want more choices for the screen. That's when they started doing the, you know, okay, these are similar to your dates. Remember, they started putting the under the bottom, you know. I know you want to go from the 19th to the 25th, but if you go on the 18th to the 23rd, you can get this spot, you know. They started doing that, which is cool, and you'll be popping up more, but then on the other end, the more places are gonna be popping up, it's not gonna really narrow you down.
SPEAKER_04Airbnb, I noticed they don't ever want to be in a place in a position where every all every amenity you check isn't available, so they're just gonna show you something, but they'll tell you, hey, this is missing. Um, you know, and that goes into like you know, when the um air cover and all that came out, you know, they start offering yurts and weird cabins and a-frame housing, you know, they let those be selectable amenities for a house that you want. So yeah, Airbnb is definitely onto that. So they like you said, they do the research for you, you just gotta follow it.
SPEAKER_01Love it, man. Great episode.
SPEAKER_04All right, good episode. Yeah, so uh, thank y'all for continuing to listen. You can email us at livelethrive at gmail.com. You can email Steve personally, chessardenrock at gmail.com, hit us up, follow us on IG. We're gonna be pumping out some content for you. So uh yeah, man. Thank y'all for continuing to listen to us. And uh, oh yeah, be the be sure to join the Facebook group.
SPEAKER_01Facebook group, baby. We're gonna start doing some meetups here in Dallas, and it's gonna be some good times. Uh all the Dallas people come out, and then we might even record them, you know, do some virtual stuff for you guys. So it's gonna be uh yeah, we're this is a year of growth for LLT. It's coming, it's coming.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, we we definitely gonna be doing doing some big stuff coming. And yeah, yeah. Speaking of the meetup, we do have a meetup in Dallas on March 10th. I already had one person confirmed he's flying in to come. So yeah, definitely, yeah, definitely check it out. Uh our our good friend Peyton, he's gonna fly in to come see it, to come to it. So yeah, man. So if y'all want to come to the Dallas meetup, um, you can follow it in the Live Let Thrive Facebook group, or you can also uh check it out on my Instagram. I post it on my Instagram as well. So uh hope to see y'all there. We are out.
SPEAKER_00Peace. Thank you for tuning in to this week's episode of Live Let Thrive. Be sure to tune in next week for all the latest in the world of Airbnb and all that entails. Bye bye.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Real Estate Rookie
BiggerPockets
Entrepremarriage
Myka & Mahogany
The Co-Living Show
Craig Curelop and Miller McSwain
BiggerPockets Real Estate Podcast
BiggerPockets
LEAN Podcast
Mahogany